THE REFORMS OF HIGHER EDUCATION: HISTORICAL RETROSPECTION IN MODERN REFLECTION

Keywords: the Russian empire, Naddniprianska Ukraine, higher education reforms, government offi cials of the conservative camp, government offi cials of the liberal camp, studentship, professorate, the public

Abstract

The article deals with the process of the development and introduction of higher education reforms in the second half of the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries in the territory of the Russian Empire. Considering the fact that Naddniprianska Ukraine was a part of the empire, all the reform processes of that time had an effect on its higher educational institutions. The introduction of university charters in 1863, 1884 and attempts to establish the reforms in 1905 are examined. At present, historical retrospection is extremely important, as the current course of education reforms in Ukraine refl ects the same problems that the generation of reformers of the past faced. In the middle of the 19th century as well as even today there are three issues that remain urgent: the level of state intervention in education; rights and opportunities of students and their participation in decision-making; the level of adopting European practices and management principles. Modern reformers are actively trying to solve them. Therefore, the paper presents their analysis, taking into account above all the evaluation of participants of the reform process of the specifi ed period, the then professors, politicians and the public. The mistakes made by offi cials are analysed and the depth of the acquired experience is discussed. Special attention is given to the struggle for the concept of reforms between government representatives of liberal and conservative views. The recommendations for modern authors and initiators of education reforms in Ukraine are presented.

References

1. Babst, I.K. (1870). Ot Moskvy do Leiptsiga [From Moscow to Leipzig]. St. Petersburg [in Russian].

2. Vernadskii, V.I. (1901). Ob osnovaniiakh universitetskoi reformy [About fundamentals of the university reform]. Moscow [in Russian].

3. Vinogradov, P.G. (1901). Uchebnoe delo v nashikh universitetakh [Training at our universities]. Vestnik Evropy, 10, 537–573 [in Russian].

4. Vorobev, V.A. (1905). K istorii nashikh universitetskikh ustavov [The background of our university charters]. Russkaia mysl, 12, 1–11 [in Russian].

5. Vospominaniia Ministra narodnogo prosveshcheniia, grafa I.I. Tolstogo. S 31 oktiabria 1905 – 24 aprelia 1906 [Memoirs of the Ministry of Public Education, count I.I. Tolstogo. From October 31, 1905 till April 24, 1906], (1997). Moscow [in Russian].

6. Georgievskii, P.I. (1909). O reforme universitetov v Rossii [About the reform of universities in Russia]. St. Petersburg [in Russian].

7. Glinskii, B.B. (1900). Universitetskie ustavy (1755–1884 gg.) [University charters]. Istoricheskii vestnik, 1–2 [in Russian].

8. Golovnin, A.V. (1997). Zapiski dlia nemnogikh [Notes for few people]. Voprosy istorii, 1–2, 102 [in Russian].

9. Dzhanshiev, G. Epokha reform. Reforma obrazovaniia [The epoch of reforms. Education reform]. St. Petersburg [in Russian].

10. Donin, A.N. (2003). Reformy universitetov i srednei shkoly Rossii: obshchestvennaia mysl i praktika vtoroi poloviny ХІХ veka [Reforms of universities and secondary school in Russia: social thought and practice of the latter half of 20th century]. Doctor’s thesis. Moscow [in Russian].

11. Zapiska grafa N.P. Ignateva ministru vnutrennikh del M.T. Loris-Melikovu [The note of count N.P. Ignatev to the minister of internal affairs to M.T. Loris-Melikov], (1881). St. Petersburg [in Russian].

12. Zapiska professora imperatorskogo Kharkovskogo universiteta Kachenovskogo [The note of professor of imperial Kharkiv university Kachnovskyi]. Zamechaniia na proekt obshchego ustava universitetov 1863 g. (Part 1), (pp. 322–325) [in Russian].

13. Ikonnikov, V.S. (1876). Russkie universitety v sviazi s khodom obshchestvennogo razvitiia [Russian universities in connection with the process of social development]. Vestnik Evropy, 9–11 [in Russian].

14. Kavelin, K.D. (1899). Nauka i universitety na Zapade i u nas [Science and universities in the Western world and here at home]. Sobranie sochinenii. (Vol. 3). St. Petersburg [in Russian].

15. Kapterov, P.F. (1910). Istoriia russkoi pedagogiki [History of Russian pedagogics]. St.Petersburg [in Russian].

16. Kessou, S.D. (1993). Universitetskii ustav 1863 g.: novaia tochka zreniia [University charter of 1863: a new point of view]. Velikie reformy v Rossii. 1856–1874, 317–334. Moscow [in Russian].

17. Kostomarov, N. (1863). O prepodavanii na rodnom iazyke v Iuzhnoi Rossii [About teaching in the native language in South Russia]. Golos, April 20, 365 [in Russian].

18. Liubimov, N.A. (1876). Universitetskie pisma [University letters]. Moscow [in Russian].

19. Miliukov, P.N., Yefron Yo.A. & Brokhauz F.A. (1902). Universitety v Rossii [Universities in Russia]. Entsiklopedicheskii slovar – Encyclopaedical dictionary. St. Petersburg. (Vol. ХХХІV),(pp. 788–800) [in Russian].

20. Nelidov, N.K. (1872). Nauka o hosudarstve kak predmet vyssheho spetsialnoho obrazovaniia [The Science of the State as a Subject of Higher Special Education]. Vremennik Demidovskoho litseya – Chronicle of Demidov lyceum (3) (p. 107) [in Russian].

21. Nikitenko, A.V. (1904). Dnevnik [Dairy]. Moscow. (Vol. 2) (p. 46) [in Russian].

22. Obiasnitelnaia zapiska k proektu ustava imperatorskikh rossiiskikh universitetov [Explanatory note to draft regulation of the empire Russian universities]. (1863) (peredruk 1910 r. – reedited of 1910) St. Petersburg [in Russian].

23. Otvet soveta imperatorskoho Kharkovskoho universiteta na voprosy, predlozhennyie Ministerstvom narodnoho porsveshcheniia ob izmenenii ustava 1884 g. [The answer of the board of the Imperial Kharkov University to the questions proposed by the Ministry of Public Education about the change of the 1884 charter] (1901) (X) (p. 13). Rukopys – Manuscript [in Russian].

24. Pirogov, N.I. (1887). Vzhliad na obshchii ustav dlia nasikh universitetov. Sochineniia. [A view at the general charter for our universities. Thesis]. (Vol. 2.). St. Petersburg [in Russian].

25. Pisarev, D.I. (1863). Nasha universitetskaia nauka. Sochineniia [Our university study. Thesis]. (Vol. 2.). (peredruk M. of 1955 r. – reedited Moscow of 1955). St. Petersburg [in Russian].

26. Predlozheniia Komisii SPU ob izmeneniiakh b ustave [The Recommendations of the Board of SPU on the changes in the charter]. Vestnik Evropy – gazette of Europe (1901). 10 [in Russian].

27. Redkin, P.G. (1889). Lektsii [Lectures]. (Vol. 1.), (p. 27) St. Petersburg [in Russian].

28. Rennenkamf, M.K. (1899). Kievskaia universitetskaia starina [Kiev university old times]. Russkaia starina 1899 – Russian old times of 1899 – (part 7), (pp. 34–49), (p. 5) [in Russian].

29. Rudolf-fon-Raumer. (1863). Klassicheskoe obrazovanie [Classical education] Zamechaniia innostrannykh pedahohov na proekty ustavov – The remarks of foreign educators on the project of the charters. (p. 396), (p. 5). St. Petersburg [in Russian].

30. Trubetskoy, S.N. Universitet i studenchestvo (1897). [Universityy and studentshipp]. Ruskaia mysl. – Russian idea. (4), (pp. 181–203) [in Russian].

31. Ustrialov, F.N. (1884). Vospominaniia o Sankt-Peterburhskom universitete in 1852– 1856 gg. [The memories about St. Petersburg University in 1852–1856s] Istoricheskii vestnik – Historic gazette, 6–8 [in Russian].

32. Frommet, B.R. (1912). Ocherki po istorii studenchestva v Rosii [Stories on history of studentship in Russia] St. Petersburg, Moscow [in Russian].

33. Chicherin, B.I. (1900) Rossiia na kanune XX stoletiia [Russia on the eve of XXth century] Berlin [in Russian].

34. Sharavara, T.O. (2011.) Reformy i kontrrformy drugoi polovyny XIX–XX stolittia v Rosiiskii imperii: istoriografi ia [Reforms and counter reforms in the second half of the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries in the territory of the Russian Empire: historiography]. Doctor’s thesis. Kyiv [In Ukrainian].

35. Shmidt, L. (1863) Zamechaniia innostrannykh pedahohov na proekty ustavov [The remarks of foreign teachers on the charter draft] (p. 396), (p. 191), (p. 133) St. Petersburg [in Russian].

36. Shmidt, E. (1878) Istoriai srednikh uchebnykh zavedenii v Rosii [History of secondary institutions in Russia] St. Petersburg [in Russian].

37. Alston, P. (1969). Education and the State in tsarist Russia. Stanford.

38. McCleland, J. (1970). Autocrats and Academics. Chicago.

39. Methes, W. (1966). The Struggle for University Autonomy in Russia during the First Decade of Reigh of Alexandr II (1855–1866). Candidate’s thesis. Columbia university.

40. Meyer, K. (1978). L’history de la guestion universittate au ХІХ siècle. Cahiers du Monde Russe et Sovietige, 3, 301–303.

41. Stepashko, V.O. (2017). Technology of Competitive Selection of Candidates For The Position of A Rector of A Higher Educational Institution. Osvita i nauka, 8, 5–14.

42. Vichnich, A. (1970). Science in Russian Culture. (Vol. II), (pp. 66–104). Stanford.

Author Biographies

Tamara Sharavara

Doctor of Historical Sciences, Assistant Professor, Poltava State
Agrarian Academy.

Roman Sharavara

Candidate of Economical Sciences, Assistant Professor, Poltava
Institute of Economics and Law of «Ukraine» University.

Published
2018-04-02
How to Cite
Sharavara, T., & Sharavara, R. (2018). THE REFORMS OF HIGHER EDUCATION: HISTORICAL RETROSPECTION IN MODERN REFLECTION. Pereiaslav Chronicle, (13), 53-63. Retrieved from https://pc-journal.org/index.php/journal/article/view/17
Section
CHAPTER І. PAGES OF UKRAINIAN HISTORY